Book Review: The Cruelest Months by Dorothy K. Fletcher

Donna Webster, a white woman, has just completed a degree in English education from Florida State University. She returns to her hometown of Jacksonville to begin her teaching career, and she is assigned to Paul Lawrence Dunbar Senior High School, a primarily black high school in the north side of town.

Anxious, scared, nauseous the first day of school, she is comforted by a colleague who advises her, when meeting her students, to "save the smiles until after Christmas," but as soon as Donna smiles at a student who immediately smiles back, she forgets that advice. Thus begins her year of challenge, as she works diligently, with her heart as her guide, to teach her students literature and grammar, while helping them face emotional issues of young life.

The Cruelest Months, though a work of fiction, is based on the actual experiences of the author, Dorothy K. Fletcher. Beginning with her first day of school, she relates her experiences month by month, as the school year progresses. Each month consists of several lessons, or stories. Fletcher begins each story with a literary quote, often from the text from which her lesson is taken, but sometimes the quotes reflect an idea or concept important to her anecdote. For example, Fletcher uses the poem To an Athlete Dying Young by A.E. Houseman to introduce her narration of a shooting that occurred in the parking lot after a football game.

Fletcher's character, Donna Webster, wants to share her love of literature, and she tries to reach her students by making connections they can understand. When teaching Beowulf, Donna tries to relate the literary character to the school's mascot, the Viking, as well as to Arnold Schwarzenegger as the Terminator in a bear skin coat. In a lesson on Edgar Allen Poe's The Raven, she asks a student to drum a rap rhythm on a cabinet and then reads the poem aloud to the beat of the rhythm. Soon other students, and eventually the entire class, join her in rapping The Raven. Through perseverance, creativity and love, Webster inspires many of her students. However, not all her experiences end well, and she must face rebellious students as she struggles to keep her classes focused.

One very angry student, Rochelle, is especially a challenge. She enters school a week late, disheveled and unclean. She picks fights with other students and is the object of their teasing. One day Donna asks her to read aloud a passage from Sojourner Truth, a slave woman whose life was full of adversity and suffering. While reading, Rochelle becomes transformed, and Donna sees her smile for the first time. Donna asks Rochelle to join the weekly student poetry session, and through poetry, her own as well as that of others, Rochelle loses her anger and starts to love herself and the world. Unfortunately, however, Rochelle ultimately becomes a victim, and Donna must endure sadness and loss.

At one point, Donna is encouraged by another teacher who tells her why teaching is so important: "We teachers rarely get to see the fruits of our labors. School years pass so quickly, and the kids are out the door before we know it. I guess that's why I call teaching a 'leap of faith profession.' You just have to believe you planted a positive seed of some kind; and even though you're not the one who will get to see it grow, you have to believe it WILL grow."

"Sometimes," she continued, "I feel like I haven't made the slightest difference at all. Then, years later, in the grocery store or at the K-Mart, a stranger will come up to me and go on and on about how I touched him so deeply or I was there when she needed me the most. Some have even told me I have made all the difference in their lives."

As the year ends, Donna reflects, "The lessons I taught, I would file alphabetically in metal cabinets, and the lessons I learned I would tuck neatly in some corner of my heart, ready to remember and use every time I need to remember what is good and most meaningful about life — the children."

After reading The Cruelest Months, one feels a bit of the emotional and physical tiredness of this first-year teacher. From the physical stamina needed to prepare lessons and grade papers, to the joys of seeing students relate a poem to their own lives and to the heartbreak of finding out a young life has been ended, The Cruelest Months shows the dedication and love of a teacher.

Danita Sain Stokes
Freelance Writer

Copyright 2004 Women's Digest, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Tell your friends about this page!